FNCA

Research Reactor Network workshop

MENU
image
- Project Review
- Massage from the Project Leader
- Introduction of the Project Leaders

Workshop


FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network

Report of
FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

September 24-27, 2013
Almaty, Kazakhstan



FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network (RRN) was held from September 24 to 27, 2013, in Almaty, Kazakhstan. This Workshop was hosted by National Nuclear Center (NNC) of Kazakhstan and Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) of Japan.

RRN Workshop was attended by 17 participants from 11 FNCA member countries, namely Australia, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Japan, Kazakhstan, Korea, Malaysia, Mongolia, the Philippines, Thailand and Vietnam including workshop staffs.

This project started from 2011 and this is 3rd year of 1st phase, mainly status of the research/test reactors and isotope production in their countries were reported and their possible regional network in Asia was discussed.

[ Plenary Session of ICNRP-09/FNCA ]

We had the plenary session of this workshop and ICNRP-09 (9th International Conference "Nuclear and Radiation Physics") which were held at the same period.

Session 6, Dr. Machi gave a lead speech on future plan of the project of RRN including possible 3 year extension of the project, and followed by the discussion.

In Session 7, wrap-up of the WS including presentation of short summary report for FNCA 14th Ministerial Level Meeting was summarized. The Workshop drew to a successful close with closing remarks by Dr. Machi and Dr. Batyrbekov.

[ Joint Open Seminar of ICNRP-09 / FNCA ]

The reports on the research and test reactors, medical RI were delivered from Kazakhstan, Russia, Australia, Korea, Uzbekistan, Japan and Indonesia.


Presentation of Dr. Kaminaga (Japan)

Joint Open Seminar

[ Technical Visit ]

The participants visited main facilities in Institute of Nuclear Physics (INP), namely the WWR-K reactor, Radiochemistry and Isotope Production Center.



Summary Report of
FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

24-27 September, 2013
Almaty, Kazakhstan




Conclusion and Recommendation

The meeting noted the following outcomes:

1. ANSTO's LEU Mo-99 production capacity will increase from 1000 6-day Ci/week to 3500 6-day Ci/week by the end of 2015.
2. The demand of Mo-99 is stable or increasing in developing countries such as China, India and Bangladesh whilst the demand for Mo-99 in Japan is decreasing due to the expanding use of alternative imaging methods.
3. PT Batan Teknologi will construct new reactor to produce Mo-99 by joint financing with US company. The reactor using liquid fuels has Mo-99 production capacity of 4400 Ci(6d)/week. Capital investment is US$165 million. The plant is scheduled to start operation in 2017 in the US.
4. The production capacity of Mo-99 in the FNCA region will exceed 6000Ci/week by 2017, which is larger than the projected regional demand of approximately 3000Ci/week, excluding China (who were unable to attend this meeting).
5. On this basis it is expected that these new Mo-99 production facilities will ensure the stable supply of Mo-99 in FNCA region after 2016.
6. No near term (2014/2015) shortage of Mo-99 supply was anticipated by any of the FNCA countries. Many countries acknowledged that they currently source part of their Mo-99 requirements from countries outside the region.
7. Member(s) commented on detrimental quality control issues experienced with certain regional supply of Mo-99, highlighting the importance of harmonization of quality of Mo-99 for enhancement of export and import in the FNCA region.

FNCA Regional network for stable supply of medical isotopes

8. The majority of member countries have now set up national network for demand and supply of medical isotopes and each includes an identified point-of-contact. Indonesia and Malaysia are in the process of setting up their respective networks.
9. The meeting agreed that it was important for the newly established national networks to report back to the FNCA regional network at their regular meetings.
10. In future the FNCA regional network will provide an information exchange forum that can interface with the activities of the OECD/NEA High-Level Group on the Security and Supply of Medical Isotopes for the stable regional supply of Mo-99.
11. The meeting recommended that Australia, Japan and Korea, each of which are members of OECD/NEA, should facilitate linking the regional FNCA network with the global NEA network on Mo-99 supply. Australia, Japan and Korea agreed to report back on information from the NEA network and also convey messages from the FNCA network as required.
12. The meeting recognized that supply of medical isotopes is currently secured on a commercial basis without any serious obstacles.
13. It was recommended that the FNCA network should also coordinate with the CJK (Group of CIRA, JRIA, KRIA) and WCI. The current agreement of the CJK congress will expire in 2014, and the three associations are to seriously consider whether the congress should be extended or terminated.

Construction of new research/test reactors in FNCA countries

The meeting noted the following outcomes:

14. Vietnam will start construction of new multi-purpose research reactor in 2015 that is scheduled to be operational in 2018. The 10 MW reactor will have the potential to be increased to 20 MW reactor at a later date.
15. Korea has officially launched its new research reactor project. The new 20MW reactor will be used for the production of isotopes and irradiation of silicon for the semi-conductor industry. The new reactor will commence operation in 2017, with the isotope production anticipated in 2018.
16. Thailand has an existing project to construct a new multi-purpose research reactor to meet national needs. The construction schedule has yet to be finalized.
17. Bangladesh also has plans to construct new 10 MW research reactor..

Cooperation for Design, Application of Research/Test Reactor

18. JAEA reported that budget restrictions have limited its ability to invite nuclear engineers from FNCA countries to jointly study design of advanced research/test reactor. However, one nuclear engineer from Mongolia will study reactor design with Dr. Kaminaga's group under funding provided by the MEXT Nuclear Researcher Exchange Program in 2013.
19. The meeting expressed the hope that JAEA will coordinate its Asian regional cooperation on reactor engineering to align with a future FNCA workshop meeting, perhaps in 2014, to facilitate broader exchange of information.
20. The importance of sharing information on the specifications for the design, construction and operation of research/test reactor was noted, in view of the new reactors planned in Vietnam, Korea, Thailand and Bangladesh.

2nd Phase of the RRN Project

21. The meeting agreed that the RRN project should be extended to a 2nd cycle to achieve the updated goals and specific objectives described in the attached plan.

Plan for 2nd Phase (2014-2016) of the RRN Project

1. Operation of the regional network for stable production and supply of medical isotopes, in particular Mo-99 in member countries by the close collaboration with the national networks for planning of stable supply to meet national demand.
2. Establishment of linkage with NEA/OECD to harmonize activities for the stable supply of Mo-99 through Australia, Japan and Korea which are the member of OECD in order to ensure the stable supply by the global network.
3. Sharing information on updated status of production, demand and supply of medical isotopes in Member Countries.
4. Sharing information on the technology to produce Mo-99 by using n-gamma reaction.
5. Sharing information on the technology on neutron doping into silicone for semiconductor production by using research reactor.
6. Sharing information on the design of reactor and irradiation facilities for applications in connection with the plans of new research reactor constructions in Korea, Vietnam and Thailand.
7. Joint study on design of advanced research/test reactor to enhance HRD of nuclear engineer for Member Countries.



Program of
FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project


Co-Host Organization : National Nuclear Center of Kazakhstan AEC MINT
Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan (MEXT)
Period : 24-27, September, 2013
Venue : Institute of Nuclear Physics AEC MINT

Day1(September 24)

Plenary Session of ICNRP-09/FNCA
Opening ceremony

Chair: Kazakhstan
10:00 Welcome speech:
  Dr. Chakrov Peter, Acting as Director General INP
  Dr. Batyrbekov, Chairman of organizational committee
10:25 The State and Prospects of National Nuclear Center of the Republic of Kazakhstan Development
  :Dr. Batyrbekov, DG, National Nuclear Center, Kazakhstan
10:55 Nuclear Physics in Kazakhstan: Science, Technology, Safety, Cooperation
  :Dr. Chakrov Peter, Acting as Director General INP
11:25 Break (Move to FNCA workshop venue)

FNCA Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

11:30

Opening Session
Chair: Kazakhstan
Welcome remarks:
  Dr. Batyrbekov, DG, National Nuclear Center, Kazakhstan
Opening address and adaption of agenda:
  Dr. Machi, FNCA Coordinator of Japan
Self-introduction of participants and group photo

12:00 < Session 1 > Overview and Progress of FNCA
Chair: Bangladesh
1. Report on Achievement of Projects and FNCA Ministerial Meeting in 2012-13:
  Dr. MACHI, FNCA Coordinator of Japan
2. Overview and Challenges of Research Reactor Network Project:
  Dr. Kaminaga, JAEA, Japan
12:45 Lunch Break
13:50 < Session 2 > Country report on research/test reactor and their applications
Country report should include following points
  1) Isotope demand and its production
  2) Status of research and test reactor used for isotope production
  3) Plan for new research reactors and/or upgrading existing reactors
  4) Challenges of reactor management
< Session 2-1 >Presentation from Bangladesh, Indonesia, Japan, Kazakhstan and Korea (20 min. each)
Chair: Vietnam
15:30 Coffee break
15:50 < Session 2-2 > Presentation from Malaysia, Mongolia, the Philippines and Thailand (20 min. each)
Chair: Thailand
17:10 Adjournment
 
Day 2(September 25)
Joint Open Seminar of ICNRP-09 (4-th Section) and FNCA
Chair: Dr. Batyrbekov, DG, National Nuclear Center, Kazakhstan
09:30 Nuclear Program of Kazakhstan and Challenges for Development
  Dr. Kenzhin Y.A., Deputy DG, National Nuclear Center, Kazakhstan
10:00 Technical & commercial proposal for the first-of-the-kind nuclear technological complex for production of medical isotopes (Mo-99, Sr-89) based on innovative solution technology
  A.V. Goryachikh, Russia
10:30 Successful Design and Application of Research Reactor "Opal" in Australia
  Dr. Bruce Begg, ANSTO, Australia
11:00 Application of HANARO reactor in Korea
  Mr. Park Ul Jae, Mr. Nam Ho, Korea
11:15 Break
Chair: Kodina G.E., Russia
11:30 Roles and Application of Research Reactor and Upgraded Test Reactor, JMTR in Japan
  Dr. Masanori Kaminaga, JAEA, Japan
12:00 Sorption Materials Based on Bentonite Clays for Separation of Radionuclides
  Egamediev S.H., Nurbaeva D.A., Uzbekistan, INP UzAS
12:30 Application of RSG-GAS 30 MW Research Reactor Application and Isotope Application in Indonesia
  Ms. Endang Susilowati, BATAN, Indonesia
13:00 Lunch

FNCA Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

16:00 < Session 2-3 > Presentation from Vietnam and Australia (20 min. each)
Chair: Japan
16:40 < Session 2-4 > Discussion, summary and conclusion
Chair: Japan
17:30 Adjournment
 
Day 3(September 26)

FNCA Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

09:00 < Session 3 > Status of establishment of the national network for isotope production and stable supply of isotopes
Chair: Philippines
Short country report on setting national network for isotope production and stable supply of isotopes (5 min. per country)
11:00 Discussion on remaining task and challenges for national network
< Session 4 > Setting up FNCA regional network for stable isotope production and supply of isotopes
Chair: Australia
Lead speech: Dr. Machi, FNCA Coordinator of Japan
11:20 Discussion and conclusion
Points of discussion (participants should be prepared for statement):
  (1) Periodical meeting of focal persons of member states to coordinate production strategy of isotopes to secure stable supply of medical isotopes
  (2) Setting one regional office for coordination and arrangement of the meeting (rotational basis)
  (3) Funding issue to operate the network (self-financing)
  (4) Coordination with commercial supply network
  (5) Implementation plan
12:30 Lunch Break
13:30 < Session 4 > Setting up FNCA regional network for stable isotope production and supply of isotopes (Continued)
Chair: Australia
   Discussion and conclusion (Continued)
14:30 Conclusion
15:00 Coffee break
15:15 < Session 5 > Cooperation for Design, Application of Research/Test Reactor
Chair: Mongolia
Lead speeches:
  1.Joint study on design new research/test reactor for HRD: Dr. Kaminaga, JAEA, Japan
  2.Plan and design concept of new research reactor in Vietnam: Mr. DUONG Van Dong, VINATOM, Vietnam
  3.Plan and design concept of new isotope production reactor in Korea: Mr. PARK Ul Jae, KAERI, Korea
  4.Plan and design concept of new research reactor in Thailand: Mr. Chanatip TIPPAYAKUL, TINT, Thailand
16:15 Discussion
Point of discussion:

  1.How to cooperate for better design of new reactor to meet demands using existing experience and knowledge of member countries
  2.Challenge for human resource development (HRD) for research/test reactor
  3.Roles of research/test reactor for introduction of the 1st nuclear power plant
17:30 Adjournment
 
Day 4(September 27)

FNCA Workshop on Research Reactor Network Project

09:00 < Session 6 > Future plan of the Project of RRN including possible 3 year extension of the project
Chair: Malaysia
Lead speech: Dr. Machi, Japan
09:30 Discussion and conclusion
Point of discussion:
  1.Setting and operation of medical RI production network
  2.Strategy for industrial application of research reactor, such as silicon doping and large Co-60 source
  3.Strategy for human resource development for research/test reactor
  4.Significance of application of reactors for basic research
11:00 Coffee break
11:15 < Session 7 > Conclusion and recommendation
Chair: Korea
Discussion on the draft report for adaption
12:00 Closing remarks:
  Dr. Batyrbekov, DG, National Nuclear Center, Kazakhstan
  Dr. Machi, FNCA Coordinator of Japan
12:30 Lunch beak
13:30 Technical visit

Participant list
FNCA 2013 Workshop on Research Reactor Network

September 24-27, 2013
Almaty, Kazakhstan



Australia

Dr. Bruce Begg
Leader, Business Development, Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation(ANSTO)

Bangladesh

Prof. Dr. Shahana AFROZ
Member (Biological Science), Bangladesh Atomic Energy Commission (BAEC)

Indonesia

Ms. Endang SUSILOWATI
Reactor Operation Division, Center for Multipurpose Reactor, National Nuclear Energy Agency of Indonesia (BATAN)

Japan

Dr. Sueo Machi
FNCA Coordinator of Japan

Dr. Tatsuo IDO
Executive Director, Japan Radioisotope Association

Dr. Masanori KAMINAGA
Deputy Director, Japan Materials Testing reactor,
Oarai Research and Development Center,
Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA)

Ms. Chiaki Inokoshi
International Affairs and Research Department,
Nuclear Safety Research Association (NSRA)

Kazakhstan

Ms. Yelena Chakrova
Head of Radiochemistry and Isotope Production Center,
Institute of Nuclear Physics of National Nuclear Centre of the Republic of Kazakhstan

Mr. Sergey KOTOV
Lead Manager, JSC "Park of Nuclear technology"

Korea

Mr. Nam HO
International Coordinator, World Council on Isotopes (WCI)

Mr. PARK Ul Jae
Principal Researcher, Radioisotope Research Division, Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI)

Malaysia

Mr. Azahari KASBOLLAH
Research Officer, Medical Technology Division, Malaysian Nuclear Agency

Mongolia

Mr. Chadraabal MAVAG
Acting Director of Nuclear Technology Department, Nuclear Energy Agency of the Government of Mongolia

Ms. Otgontsetseg TSERENDORJ
Officer of Nuclear Technology Department, Nuclear Energy Agency of the Government of Mongolia

The Philippines

Mr. Neil Raymund GUILLERMO
Supervising Science Research Specialist,
Philippine Nuclear Research Institute (PNRI)

Thailand

Mr. Chanatip TIPPAYAKUL
Nuclear Engineer, Nuclear Technology and Reactor Operation Division,
Thailand Institute of Nuclear Technology (TINT)

Vietnam

Mr. Duong Van Dong
Director, Center for Research and Production of Radioisotope,
Nuclear Research Institute (NRI),
Vietnam Atomic Energy Institute (VAEI)






Report>>  Summary Report>>  Program>>  List of Participants>>

Forum for Nuclear Cooperation in Asia